Ramban on Shelach: Who Sent the Spies and Why?
Rabbi Ezra Bick
We examine the question of motivation of the Jews, Moshe and God in sending the spies. The questionis framed by discrepancies between the accounts in Bemidbar and Devarim.
Was it wrong to want to investigate scout out the land? Was God merely enabling them? Were they asking for military preparation purposes or for a general feeling of encouragement?
Ramban seems to think that sending the spies was initially a good thing. What accounts for the negative portrayal of the request to scout out the land in Devarim? The attitudes may have changed- at the beginning, the people had the right mindset, but then something shifted.
לשאר השיעורים בסדרה (30)
- Ramban on Vayeira - Sedom and Pilegesh baGiv'a
- Ramban on Parshat Naso - Your Individual Task
- Ramban on Chayyei Sara: The Burial of Sarah in Eretz Yisrael - the Location of the Cave of Makhpela
- Ramban on Parshat Behaalotecha - Pesach Sheni
- Ramban on Toldot: Did the Avot Keep the Torah?
- Ramban on Vayikra - Appeasement and Atonement
- Ramban on Vayishlach: The Massacre in Shechem
- Ramban on Tzav - Derech Eretz
- Ramban on Yitro: Hearing God's Voice at Har Sinai
- Ramban on Parshat Miketz - But We are Guilty For Our Brother
- Ramban on Tazria - Ki HaDavar Nes
- Why is Para Aduma Called "Chuka"?
- Ramban on Vayeshev - "And Yaakov Settled as a Stranger"
- Ramban on Acharei Mot Kedoshim - Sa'ir LaAzazel
- Bilam and the Daughters of Moav
- Ramban on Vaera: The Hardening of Pharoah's Heart
- Ramban on Parshat Emor - Mikraei Kodesh
- Why Kill Midyan and Spare Moav?
- Ramban on Vayechi: BeCharvi u-veKashti - With My Sword and Bow
- Ramban on Behar Bechukotai
- Ramban on Matot Masei - Cities and Name Changes
- Ramban on Bo: HaChodesh HaZeh Lachem - This Month is for You
- Ramban on Bamidbar: "Tifkedu Otam" - Remembrance and Supervision
- God Gave the Land of Moav to the Moabites
- Ramban on Teruma: The Mishkan and the Divine Presence
- Ramban on Rosh HaShana: What is the Secret of the Terua?
- Ramban on Mishpatim: "Justice Belongs to God"
- Ramban on Parshat Ki Tavo
- Ramban on Beshallach: Tze'aka - Crying Out
- Ramban on Parshat Nitzavim - Transcending Free Will